Of course, that is purely speculation - since, again, Pi does not elaborate on the more grounded human story beyond the revelation that he was alone on the lifeboat.Even if the connection between the lifeboat parties was missed, the writer makes the connection for the audience (or readers): the hyena is the cook, the orangutan is Pi's mother, the zebra is the sailor, and Richard Parker is Pi.Though, for every mention of 's beautiful 3D or amazing CGI tiger, there's a fuddled viewer confused by the movie's controversial ending.Tags: Cause And Effect Of Road Accident EssayExtended Essay Business Management CriteriaAn Experience That Changed My Life EssayFeminist Perspective EssayBeauty Is Better Than Brains EssayPoem HomeworkWriting College EssayHow To Solve Programming ProblemsDefining Essay SuccessHow Technology Help People In The World Essay
Pi does not mention his other adventures at sea (the carnivorous island, etc) but it'd be easy to strip away some of the fantastical elements in favor of more grounded (albeit allegorical) situations.
Maybe he found an island but realized that living is more than just eating and existing - deciding to take his chances at sea instead of wasting away in apathy on a beach eating meerkats all alone.
We explain what really happened to Pi and Richard Parker in the film (and book) as well as what it all means.
Ang Lee's film racked-up critical acclaim (read our review) and pre-award season buzz along with solid box office numbers.
As a result, the larger question is impossible to answer definitively and, as mentioned, the "truth" of Pi's story is of little concern to Martel or Lee.
The real question is - which story do you, the viewer/reader prefer?
In this version of Pi's tale, the cargo ship sinks and, during the ensuing chaos, he is joined on the lifeboat by a ragtag group of zoo animals that also managed to escape: an orangutan, a spotted hyena, a zebra with a broken leg, and a Bengal Tiger (named Richard Parker).
After some time, Pi watches helplessly as the hyena kills the zebra and then the orangutan before it is, subsequently, dispatched by Richard Parker.
However, the novel takes the scene in the opposite direction, with Pi expressing annoyance at the two men - criticizing them for wanting "a story they already know." Either way, much like the ending of Facing the final question, it can be easy to forget that, from the outset, The Writer character was promised a story that would make him believe in God.
In the first part of the narrative, we see Pi struggling to reconcile the differences between faith interpretations (Hinduism, Christianity, and Islam) - acknowledging that each of them contained valuable elements, even if they tell different stories (elements that together help him survive his ordeal at sea regardless of whether or not he was there with a tiger).