Essay On Miracles David Hume

Essay On Miracles David Hume-47
First, no miracle on record has a sufficient number of intelligent witnesses, of good moral character, who testify to a miraculous event that occurred in public and in a civilized part of the world.Second, human beings love bizarre and fantastic tales, and this irrationally inclines them to accept such tales as true.

First, no miracle on record has a sufficient number of intelligent witnesses, of good moral character, who testify to a miraculous event that occurred in public and in a civilized part of the world.Second, human beings love bizarre and fantastic tales, and this irrationally inclines them to accept such tales as true.It would be as if he argued this way: what Hume intended.

When Hume says that the laws of nature are established upon “a firm and unalterable experience,” is he claiming that the laws of nature are never violated?

If so, then his argument begs the question, assuming the very thing that needs to be proved.

According to Christian philosopher Bill Craig, “An examination of the chief competing schools of thought concerning the notion of a natural law…reveals that on each theory the concept of a violation of a natural law is incoherent and that miracles need not be so defined.” Thus, we might object that Hume’s definition of a miracle is simply incoherent.

But this is a debated point, so let’s instead turn our attention to a more pressing matter.

Craig explains the matter this way: “If two witnesses are each 99% reliable, then the odds of their both independently testifying falsely to some event are only . Hume argues that since miracles run contrary to man’s uniform experience of the laws of nature, no testimony can establish that a miracle has occurred unless “its falsehood would be more miraculous than the fact which it endeavors to establish.” Although Hume makes it sound as though establishing one miracle would require an even greater miracle, all his statement really amounts to, as John Earman rightly notes, is that no testimony is good enough to establish that a miracle has occurred unless it’s sufficient to make the occurrence of the miracle more probable than not. testimony is really ever sufficient to establish that a miracle has occurred. For it can be perfectly reasonable to accept a highly improbable event on the basis of human testimony. Suppose the evening news announces that the number picked in the lottery was 8253652. The problem, says Craig, is that Hume has not considered all of the relevant probabilities.

As Craig observes, “this is a report of an extraordinarily improbable event, one out of several million.” If we applied Hume’s principle to such a case, it would be irrational for us to believe that such a highly improbable event had actually occurred. For although it might be highly improbable that just this number should have been chosen out of all the possible numbers that been chosen.

For if an all-powerful God exists, then He is certainly capable of intervening in the natural world to bring about events which would never have occurred had nature been left to itself.

In other words, if God exists, then He can bring about miracles!

When it comes to assessing the testimony for a miracle, we cannot simply consider the likelihood of the event in light of our general knowledge of the world. Instead, we must also consider how likely it would be, if the miracle had highly improbable in light of our general knowledge of the world. But the problem with this becomes evident when one reflects upon the fact that, for the Christian, part of what’s included in our “general knowledge of the world” is the belief that God exists.

What’s more, as believers we have at our disposal a whole arsenal of arguments which, we contend, make it far more plausible than not that this belief is really true.

SHOW COMMENTS

Comments Essay On Miracles David Hume

  • Hume on Miracles - Wiley Online Library
    Reply

    Philosophers continue to debate about David Hume's case against the rationality. Hume defines a miracle as an event that a is caused by God directly, or. Dr Taylor has published a number of philosophical essays on epistemological.…

  • Hume's Miracles Issue 83 Philosophy Now
    Reply

    David Hume. Hume's Miracles. Paul Warwick considers Hume's argument against testimony concerning miracles. I have a friend who was once deeply.…

  • Miracles and David Hume
    Reply

    David Hume believed he had found an "everlasting check" against belief in miracles. His Essay on Miracles is quite inconsistent with the more radical, and.…

  • Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding - Early Modern.
    Reply

    First Enquiry. David Hume. 10 Miracles were ever so clearly revealed in scripture, it would be directly contrary to the rules of sound reasoning to give our assent.…

  • David Hume and Miracles Christian Courier
    Reply

    Philosopher David Hume failed in disproving the veracity of biblical miracles, but. This little essay has become, over the past two and one-half centuries.…

  • David Hume on the Existence of Miracles Essay.
    Reply

    In this paper I will look at David Hume's 1711-1776 discussion from the An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Section X, Of Miracles regarding.…

  • An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding David Hume
    Reply

    An Enquiry. Concerning. Human Understanding. David Hume. 72. Sect. X. Of Miracles. 6/David Hume of morals, reasoning, and criticism; and should for.…

  • David Hume and the Probability of Miracles - Project MUSE
    Reply

    David Hume and the Probability of Miracles. Barry Gower. 1. Introduction. Oflate there have been published several discussions ofDavid Hume's famous essay.…

  • The Everlasting Check Understanding Hume's Argument.
    Reply

    Jul 23, 2017. David Hume famously argued that it wasn't. In his essay Of Miracles, which appears as section 10 of his larger work An Enquiry Concerning.…

  • Essay Sample - David Hume on Miracles - OzEssay
    Reply

    Examining political theorist David Hume on the concept of miracles. Hume In explaining Hume’s critique of the belief in miracles, we must first understand the definition of a miracle. The Webster Dictionary defines a miracle as a supernatural event regarded as to define action, one of the acts worked by Christ which revealed his divinity…

The Latest from www.naslediert.ru ©