English Essay Comparing Two Poems

Unsown fields remind Owen of the wasted potential of the dead soldier’s life.He is reminded that nature is powerless and pointless against war.If it’s not that important in the poem, why am I including it? I need to compare analytically and compare ideas/themes/language/structure/form.

Tags: Writing An Essay OnlineWriteing PaperTechnology Privacy Issues EssayCurrent Topics Argument EssayFormatting Research PaperAnalysis Essay On Of A SalesmanHsc Legal Studies Crime EssayResearch Paper Summary ExampleHow To Write A Persuasive Speech On AdoptionInternational Relations Essay Topics

We’re instantly thrown into wondering if it’s acceptable for women to see such things, and if it isn’t, is it any better for men to see such things. In fact, Owen doesn’t even say that this man is a soldier, or even that he is dead. One is that he doesn’t even know who the soldier is – which shows us the absolute tragedy of war. The other thought is that by keeping the soldier anonymous, Owen is deliberately trying to show that he could be anyone.

Not only this, but Smith calls her a ‘girl’ – something more fragile, more innocent than a man. Unlike ‘him’ in Futility, a soldier who could represent anybody, Vaudevue has a name and we see her actions. One makes us think that the dead soldier could be anybody. Both show the effect of war – one by using an anonymous man to show Owen’s own thoughts, therefore the effect on him personally. Both take one individual and show the consequences of conflict on them – and by seeing one person, we learn about the effects of war on the individual. The effects in both poems seem largely psychological.

The war seems to have more of an effect on Vaudevue, however.

She doesn’t just stop at questioning her existence. She removes her uniform, ‘lunges’ into the water and lies, ‘weeping’ before letting the ‘waters close over her head’. We have the symbolism of the water – something that soothes and cleanses. Water is used in many cultures and religions as a way of cleaning yourself.

Even though the dead soldier looks as if he is just sleeping, he isn’t. He also builds on the series of questions he asks in the poem to build up to the most profound of all: “Oh what made fatuous sunbeams toil/to break earth’s sleep at all?

” Here we see how he cannot understand why the universe bothered to raise anything, to build a civilisation, when it is all for nothing. Although Come on, Come back is a narrative poem, it still uses the structure to build up to a climax, just as Owen did.

I like to compare is really about the results – the aftermath I tried to make sure I had a conclusion that brought everything together and I picked out the four key ideas and rephrased them in my answer. I know I need to use quotes to support my response.

And I know I need to pick out the best quotes – something really insightful.

In Come on, Come back Stevie Smith writes about ‘Vaudevue’, the ‘girl soldier’.

Using this persona is interesting and thought-provoking. Women often don’t fight on the front line, as this girl has, mainly because women are seen as not being able to cope with the front line and what they see. Either we all mourn his death or nobody does, because he is nameless.